Nestled in the heart of Montgomery, New York, Carmela’s Restaurant and Pizzeria has been a beloved destination for authentic Italian cuisine for nearly five decades. Since its founding in 1975, Carmela’s has been a cornerstone of the community, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere where friends and families gather to enjoy classic, home-style Italian dishes.
A Beloved Local Legacy
Today, brothers Altin and Arber—also the proud owners of the renowned 88 Charles Restaurant—carry on Carmela’s legacy. As the newest stewards of this long-standing establishment, they are committed to preserving the traditions that have made Carmela’s a local favorite while bringing fresh energy and passion to its future.
Guests can still enjoy the same comforting flavors that have defined Carmela’s for generations, from hearty pasta dishes to fresh seafood and perfectly prepared entrées. While ownership may change, the heart and soul of Carmela’s remain the same—quality food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home.
Continuing the Carmela’s Experience
we invite you to experience the tradition, flavor, and hospitality that have made Carmela’s a Montgomery favorite for nearly 50 years.
Join Us at Carmela’s
Whether you’re a longtime patron or visiting for the first time,
1021 State Rte 17K
Montgomery, NY 12549
(845) 457-3021
Today, brothers Altin and Arber—also the proud owners of the renowned 88 Charles Restaurant—carry on Carmela’s legacy. As the newest stewards of this long-standing establishment, they are committed to preserving the traditions that have made Carmela’s a local favorite while bringing fresh energy and passion to its future.
Guests can still enjoy the same comforting flavors that have defined Carmela’s for generations, from hearty pasta dishes to fresh seafood and perfectly prepared entrées. While ownership may change, the heart and soul of Carmela’s remain the same—quality food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home.
"Been coming weekly for almost a year now. Never had a bad experience and the food is consistently good. The waitresses even know my orders (yes I change it up often) by heart. Never have to wait long for a beer either."
"The food is consistently good."
- Joseph DePauw
Authentic Food, great service and completely renovated. It’s really busy but everything came out on time. Good menu and even better food.
"No one else cooks like Carmela’s."
- Larry Degroat
I stopped by for a slice of pizza and I was so impressed with the thin crust and flavor. The staff was so friendly and inviting. I will be back for a proper meal very soon.
"Better than NYC!"
- Ismet Rebolledo
This spot was LEGIT. Our home area lacks good Italian food, so we always visit as many spots as possible when visiting the area. I highly recommend the creamy pesto gnocchi and eggplant parm. My kids loved the pizza and we all enjoyed cannolis. Also, the service was top shelf. We were regularly checked on, but not overbearing. Fast and efficient food delivery. Don't miss this gem.
"Carmela's was phenomenal."
- Jason Strachman Miller
It was my first time back to Carmela's since they reopened after the fire. It is amazing how the owners took a lemon and turned it to the Best Italian Lemonade!
